Increase font size Decrease font size
 

Balanced action at a glance

Today a mainstay of the Russian arms industry, the "balanced" operation principle traces its roots back to even before World War 1. Let's have a quick retrospective at them...

Firearms based on balanced operation systems have long been specific of the Russian industry, but the roots of the design can be traced way back: take a look!

Maxim Popenker
The experimental Soviet AL-4M 5,45x39mm caliber assault rifle, engineered by Yuriy Alexandrov at the Izhmash mechanical plant in the 1970s
The experimental Soviet AL-4M 5,45x39mm caliber assault rifle, engineered by Yuriy Alexandrov at the Izhmash mechanical plant in the 1970s
A.S. Konstantinov's 5,45x39mm mm SA-006 balanced action assault rifle competed against the AK-74 design in the 1974 Soviet Army trials
A.S. Konstantinov's 5,45x39mm mm SA-006 balanced action assault rifle competed against the AK-74 design in the 1974 Soviet Army trials
Konstantinov's  5,45x39mm SA-006 balanced action experimental assault rifle, partially disassembled
Konstantinov's 5,45x39mm SA-006 balanced action experimental assault rifle, partially disassembled

A Russian perspective

The so-called “Balanced action” saw the light following several attempts to decrease recoil of rapid-firing weapons, in which rearward and forward movement parts such as bolt group created additional forces that tend to disrupt aiming efforts. This is especially true if the bolt group hits the receiver at the rearwards end of its recoiling movement.

A classic example of a gun that is known for high impact velocities of its moving parts is the Kalashnikov AK-type rifle, and all its derivatives. The mass of the moving bolt group of an AKM rifle tops about 520 grams, and under normal conditions it hits the rear end of the receiver with velocity of 3.5-4 m/s. This creates additional recoil impulse of about 2 kg*m/s, which adds another 20% to overall recoil impulse generated by the bullet and powder gases. This high moving parts impulse was indeed intentionally achieved upon engineering, as it increases the overall reliability of the gun, but in this case reliability comes at the price of decreased accuracy.

Soviet R&D programs attempting to decrease negative effect of moving parts got impulse in late 1960s, when researcher Peter Tkachev from the TsNIITochMash research institute introduced the new concept of “balanced impulse of recoiling parts”.

A 2012 production sample AEK-971 5.45x39mm assault rifle, first engineered at the Kovrov Mechanical Plant, then manufactured by ZID
A 2012 production sample AEK-971 5.45x39mm assault rifle, first engineered at the Kovrov Mechanical Plant, then manufactured by ZID
The 5,45x39mm caliber AEK-971 assault rifle (hereby field-stripped) has been adopted in limited quantities by some Russian law enforcement units
The 5,45x39mm caliber AEK-971 assault rifle (hereby field-stripped) has been adopted in limited quantities by some Russian law enforcement units
The bolt group and receiver cover of the 2012 production ZID AEK-971 5,45x39mm caliber assault rifle
The bolt group and receiver cover of the 2012 production ZID AEK-971 5,45x39mm caliber assault rifle

According to this concept, recoil impulse of the moving parts can be neutralized by the counter-recoil impulse of additional part whose weight is about the same as the bolt group's, which should move synchronously in an opposite direction.

In the 1970s, Sovied engineers developed several “balanced action” assault rifles using the then-new 5.45x39 ammunition. These included the AL-4M, developed at the Izhevsk Mechanical Plant, and the SA-006, developed at the Kovrov plant. The latter prototype, designed by A.S. Konstantinov, became the main rival to the new 5.45x39mm-caliber Kalashnikov rifle in the 1974 Soviet army trials. In fact, the SA-006 outperformed the would-be AK-74 in terms of hit probability, especially when firing from unsupported and off-hand positions or on the move. It also performed adequately well in terms of reliability and durability.

Despite these results, the Soviet Armed Forces adopted the Kalashnikov design, which was simpler, cheaper and already familiar to the industry and troops. The main reason behind this “retrograde” decision was that the Soviet establishment wanted to get a new small caliber rifle into service as quickly as possible in order to bridge the gap between the Soviet and the U.S. Forces in terms of small arms fire effectiveness. Apparently, the AK-74 was originally considered as a stop-gap measure only, as in late '70s several R&D programs were well underway to achieve marked superiority of individual assault rifle fire effectiveness over existing designs such as the AK-74 and M16A1 themselves.

The 5,45x39mm caliber A545/6P67 balanced action assault rifle, a variant of the AEK-971, has been submitted by ZID to the ongoing “Ratnik” trials to replace the AK-based designs in service with the Russian Army
The 5,45x39mm caliber A545/6P67 balanced action assault rifle, a variant of the AEK-971, has been submitted by ZID to the ongoing “Ratnik” trials to replace the AK-based designs in service with the Russian Army
A diagram from the patent, issued in 2013 to the ZID factory, explaining their improved balanced action system which allows for easy removal of entire bolt / counterweight / synchronizing gears and spring as a single unit
A diagram from the patent, issued in 2013 to the ZID factory, explaining their improved balanced action system which allows for easy removal of entire bolt / counterweight / synchronizing gears and spring as a single unit
The other competitor to the "Ratnik" trials, the Kalashnikov Concern's own AK-12 assault rifle, employs a fairly standard long-stroke piston system
The other competitor to the "Ratnik" trials, the Kalashnikov Concern's own AK-12 assault rifle, employs a fairly standard long-stroke piston system

These R&D programs extensively pursued and tested the “balanced action” principle, among many others.

As a result of these programs, the Soviet (and later, Russian) Armed Forces held the now famous “Abakan” trials that saw several balanced-action rifles being tested.

The trial was won well into the 1990s by a system based on a different approach, the Nikonov AN-94 assault rifle. Despite this apparent failure at the “Abakan” trials, two major small arms development and manufacturing centers continued their work on balanced action systems.

Those were the IZHMASH factory − whose AKB line of experimental assault rifles was designed by Mikhail Timofe'evich Kalashnikov's son, Viktor Kalashnikov − and the Kovrov Mechanical Plant (KMZ), whose designer Sergey Korshakov developed the AEK-971 assault rifle design.

Despite formal adoption, AN-94 turned out to be a practical failure, with relatively few made and issued to Russian Armed Forces during late 1990s before it production stopped for a variety of reasons. In the meantime, IZHMASH evolved balanced action rifle prototypes into the AK-107 and AK-108 production-grade rifles chambered for the 5,45x39mm, 7,62x39mm and 5,56x45mm calibers, while KMZ continued to refine its 5,45mm AEK-971 and its 7,62x39mm caliber version, known as the AEK-973.

As of today, the "balanced action" AK-107 and AK-108 assault rifles only gained limited acceptance within the Russian military
As of today, the "balanced action" AK-107 and AK-108 assault rifles only gained limited acceptance within the Russian military
The Saiga Mk-107 semi-automatic rifle, whose full-scale commercial market launch is eagerly awaited by countless shooters worldwide, is also the first full-blown attempt to manufacture a balanced-action civilian-grade firearm
The Saiga Mk-107 semi-automatic rifle, whose full-scale commercial market launch is eagerly awaited by countless shooters worldwide, is also the first full-blown attempt to manufacture a balanced-action civilian-grade firearm
For a long time, the Russian Armed Forces failed to consider balanced-action designs as a replacement for the AK-74M platform: the result was the commercial failure of the Nikonov AN-94 assault rifle
For a long time, the Russian Armed Forces failed to consider balanced-action designs as a replacement for the AK-74M platform: the result was the commercial failure of the Nikonov AN-94 assault rifle

In the early 2000s, the KMZ plant delivered an unspecified, but relatively small number of AEK-971 rifles to Russian Internal Affairs Ministry (MVD) Spetsnaz troops, and, apparently, those elite units liked AEK-971 more than AN-94 or AK-74M.

As a result, KMZ continued development of the AEK line until 2006; after that, when KMZ closed down its military production lines, the AEK-971 related designs, technologies and developments was passed to ZID (the “Degtyarov Mechanical Plant”), itself headquartered in Kovrov.

The successor of the baseline AEK-971 design, initially known as the AEK-971M and later as the A545 (official GRAU index denomination 6P67) was proposed to the ongoing “Ratnik” trials − being held by the Russian Army to find a suitable replacement to the AK/AKM platform − to compete against the updated, but still “unbalanced”, Kalashnikov-based design known as the AK-12. At the same time, limited production of AEK-971 derivatives continues at ZID for élite units of the Russian Law Enforcement community, and IZHMASH (now known as the "Kalashnikov Concern") is currently attempting to create a semi-automatic civilian version of the balanced-action AK-107 assault rifle, known as Saiga Mk-107, mainly aimed to IPSC/3-gun shooters.

The AK-107 was the first ever mass-produced firearm to employ a counterbalancing system for its moving masses
The AK-107 was the first ever mass-produced firearm to employ a counterbalancing system for its moving masses
Rate this item!Balanced action at a glance 4.9412 (17 ratings)
print

This website uses cookies to enable us to offer you the best possible user experience.

Accept